The Butterfly Story: Why We Avoid the Conversations We Need Most

There's a familiar story about a man who finds a butterfly struggling to emerge from its cocoon.

Wanting to help, he carefully cuts the cocoon open so the butterfly doesn't have to struggle.

But in the story, the butterfly emerges unable to fly.

The man's intentions were good. He wanted to make things easier. Yet in trying to remove the discomfort, he also removed something important from the process.

It's a parable, but it raises an interesting question:

What happens when we spend so much energy avoiding discomfort that we miss the opportunity to grow through it?

Think about the conversations you've been putting off.

The feedback you haven't given.

The disagreement you haven't addressed.

The question you haven't asked because you're not sure you'll like the answer.

We often know these conversations matter. So why do we avoid them?

Why Difficult Conversations Feel So Uncomfortable

Most of us don't avoid difficult conversations because we don't know they're important.

We avoid them because of what we anticipate experiencing.

We might worry about disappointing someone, creating conflict, damaging a relationship or being challenged ourselves.

And when a conversation feels threatening, something can shift inside us.

We may become defensive before the other person has finished speaking.

We may shut down, withdraw or agree just to end the discomfort.

Or we may take over, explain more, push harder or try to fix the situation as quickly as possible.

These responses can happen so automatically that we don't recognize them.

We think we're responding to the conversation. But we're also responding to what's happening inside us.

And that internal response can shape everything that happens next.

The Patterns We Don't See Under Pressure

Here's where things get interesting.

You might be someone who values open communication.

You believe in listening, asking good questions and considering different perspectives.

And when things are going well, you do all those things.

But what happens when someone disagrees with you?

When you feel criticized?

When you have to deliver feedback you know someone won't want to hear?

Suddenly, the skills you know so well can become harder to access.

You stop asking questions.

You make assumptions.

You become focused on defending your position or getting through the conversation.

Or you avoid it altogether.

Later, you may wonder why you didn't handle things differently.

Knowing how to have a difficult conversation isn't the same as understanding what happens to you when you're in one.

That's the blind spot.

We can spend years developing communication skills without recognizing the internal patterns that get in the way of using them when they matter most.

Curiosity Doesn't Mean Being Comfortable

The butterfly story reminds us that discomfort isn't always something we need to eliminate.

Sometimes it's something we need to learn how to navigate.

That doesn't mean every difficult conversation is productive, or that we should tolerate harmful behaviour.

It means recognizing that disagreement, uncertainty and uncomfortable emotions can be part of working through something important.

And curiosity can help.

Instead of assuming we know why someone behaved a certain way, we can ask.

Instead of defending our position immediately, we can explore another perspective.

Instead of rushing to resolve the discomfort, we can stay engaged long enough to understand what's really happening.

But there's a catch.

It's hard to be curious when you don't recognize that you've stopped being curious.

That's why self-awareness matters.

Before we can respond differently, we need to recognize the patterns influencing how we're responding now.

What Happens Inside You When a Conversation Gets Difficult?

Think about a conversation you've been avoiding or one that didn't go the way you hoped.

Rather than focusing on what the other person should have done differently, consider these questions:

  • What was I feeling? Was I frustrated, anxious, embarrassed, threatened or something else?

  • Where did my attention go? Was I trying to understand, or was I focused on defending myself, fixing the problem or getting out of the conversation?

  • What assumptions did I make? What did I decide was true without exploring it?

  • How did I respond? Did I stay engaged, take over, shut down or avoid the conversation?

  • What could I practise doing differently next time?

These questions aren't about judging yourself.

They're about becoming aware of patterns you may not have noticed before.

Because when you can see the pattern, you have something specific to work with.

From Avoiding Discomfort to Responding Differently

This is where I focus my work with individuals and teams.

We start by making the invisible visible.

Using the WE-I Profile, we capture what's happening internally under stress in real time, helping people recognize patterns in their emotions, attention, perspectives and relationship strategies.

From there, we build the emotional intelligence and Curious Conversation skills to respond differently.

Not just learning how to ask better questions or navigate conflict when everything is calm.

But practising those skills for the moments when you're challenged, uncomfortable or under pressure.

Because the goal isn't to become someone who never feels stressed or uncomfortable.

It's to recognize what's happening inside you and develop the ability to stay engaged, curious and effective when it matters most.

The Conversation You've Been Avoiding

Think about the conversation you know you need to have.

What's making it uncomfortable?

What are you anticipating?

And what might happen if, instead of avoiding the discomfort or trying to control the outcome, you became curious about your own response?

You can't control how the other person will react.

But you can develop a clearer understanding of yourself and practise how you want to show up.

Growth doesn't come from making every conversation comfortable. It comes from developing the awareness and skills to navigate the uncomfortable ones.

Curious what happens to you under pressure?

You know what you're capable of. But are you making your best decisions when the pressure is on?

Take the free Are You Making Your Best Decisions Under Pressure? quiz to explore how stress may be influencing your decisions, conversations and responses.

Better decisions start with understanding what's happening inside you when they matter most.


Kirsten Siggins

Kirsten Siggins is the co-author of The Power of Curiosity and founder of the Institute of Curiosity. She helps individuals and teams uncover the patterns shaping how they think, feel and respond under pressure, then build the emotional intelligence and communication skills to make better decisions and have better conversations.

https://www.instituteofcuriosity.com
Previous
Previous

Are Your Questions Opening Conversations or Shutting Them Down?

Next
Next

5 Emotional Intelligence Skills Teams Need Under Pressure